The Blog of Pastor Jude St. John

In The Trenches

One of the things I love about football is its applicability to life. So much of what happens on the football field corresponds to our experience of living. And in particular, one can draw many parallels between the game of football and our life of faith in Jesus Christ. Most of my years playing football were played “in the trenches.” That is, I was an offensive lineman who plied my trade on the line of scrimmage. That no-man’s-land of much physical violence between opposing forces which derives its name from the battle situations of the World Wars. That place which seems, as often as not, to be an experience much like our lives. I hope to communicate with you a few things that will hopefully be of some help as you fight the good fight of faith. And since I am in this battle too, you might consider that I write these thoughts as I live my life for God in the trenches. 

Books I've Read in 2019

    • John Newton by Jonathan Aitken
    • Supernatural Power for Everyday People by Jared Wilson
    • The Freedom of the Will by Jonathan Edwards
    • The World-Tilting Gospel by Dan Philips
    • Biblical Theology by Nick Roark and Robert Cline
    • Understanding the Lord's Supper by Bobby Jamieson
    • The Works of John Newton: Volume 1 by John Newton
    • Understanding the Congregation's Authority by Jonathan Leeman
    • Pierced for Our Transgressions by Steve Jeffery, Mike Ovey, and Andrew Sach
    • The Common Rule by Justin Whitmel Earley
    • The Works of John Newton: Volume 2 by John Newton
    • Heart to Heart: Octavius Winslow's Experimental Preaching by Tanner G. Turley
    • The Inquirer Directed to an Experimental and Practical View of the Atonement by Octavius Winslow
    • The Works of John Newton: Volume 3 by John Newton
    • Missions by Andy Johnson
    • The Gospel-Driven Church by Jared Wilson
    • Date Your Wife by Justin Buzzard
View RSS Feed

Archives

  • Sep22Thu

    Residual Christianity and Pain and Suffering

    September 22, 2016

    I recently began reading Timothy Keller’s book that deals with pain and suffering, aptly titled Walking with God through Pain and Suffering. Keller, a best-selling author and pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City, has so far–I’m only a fifth of the way through–delivered yet another helpful book on a topic of interest to both believers and non-believers.

    In the second chapter of the book, titled The Victory of Christianity, Keller shares some thoughts that I found quite compelling. The section of the chapter wherein these ideas are raises has “Residual Christianity and the Problem of Evil” as its sub-title. Consider the following in regards to the ascendancy of the problem of evil as a difficult doctrine:

    "It is often noted that the United States became secularized more slowly than Europe and Canada, but secularization has nevertheless moved forward. Despite the Deism of American founders such as Thomas Jefferson, several powerful spiritual awakenings kept American public culture characterized by Christian beliefs. In particular, those included the universality of human sin, that every person has a nature prone to and capable of great evil. This meant that "moral evil"–terrible suffering and pain inflicted by human beings on other human beings–was easy to explain. It was seen as part and parcel of living within the sinful human race. In addition, the doctrine of inherent human sinful ness also explained natural evil. Because we had turned from God, it was understandable that our world would be a dark and broken place, since it was under the judgment of a just God. And so earthquakes as well as invasions were occasions for public calls for widespread and repentance." (57)

    Essentially, Keller suggests that the problem of evil wasn’t a problem until recently, or at least, wasn’t as big of a problem as it has become. The reason? Christians in the past, which lived in Western countries at a much higher proportion than they do now, held certain beliefs which “dealt” with the problem of evil in a more satisfactory manner.

    Keller continues, noting the transformation of our beliefs, writing:

    And so we have come to our present day. All of Western societies live within the secular frame, and even though many people still profess fairly traditional believes in God, most are affected by this frame. We see ourselves as able to control our own destiny, able to discern for ourselves what is right and wrong, and we see God is obligated to arrange things for our benefit, especially if we live a good enough life according to our own chosen standards. (57) Keller is clear on his opinion of the effects of this doctrinal metamorphosis, bluntly stating, “this secularized belief in God, or this residue of Christianity, may be the worst possible preexisting condition in which to encounter suffering” (58).

    It seems we are ill-prepared and ill-equipped for the very things which cause us so much intellectual and emotional distress.

    Keller believes, however, that Christianity actually does possess the assets needed for walking through pain and suffering and these assets “reside in robust, distinctive Christian beliefs” (58). It is biblically rich, thick, and vigorous doctrines which furnish us for the fight of faith that invariably involves suffering. Keller notes four doctrines which particularly impact our ability to manage suffering: 1) the belief in a “personal, wise, infinite, and therefore inscrutable God who controls the affairs of the world” (58); 2) the tenet that “in Jesus Christ, God came to earth and suffered with and for us sacrificially” proving God is for us (58); the assurance of salvation for those who hold to “Christ’s work of salvation”(58) through faith; and 4) the belief that all true believers will experience bodily resurrection from the dead (58).

    These great truths, according to Keller, prepare us and equip us for experiencing suffering and pain. Though I don’t claim to have experienced great suffering, I believe this to be true and have seen this very thing played out in the lives of friends. Keller concludes this section of his book with emphatically declaring, “When suffering, believing in God thinly or in the abstract is worse than not believing in God at all” (60).

    So then, what about you? Do you believe in God thinly? Do you believe in a thin God? Do your doctrinal beliefs amount to nothing more than a residue of Christianity? If so, your journey through pain and suffering may be one in which you are less prepared than those who don’t believe in God at all.

    Comment

    On Monday, September 26, 2016, Barbara Postma said:

    I agree that this was a very interesting chapter. The book was quite helpful to me in many ways, not the least of which is understanding why suffering is 'such a problem' for us (if I can say that and have it make sense). Excellent read. And I found it just got better and better as the book went along. I love (hate?) that picture of a thin God.... very helpful in preaching gospel to oneself in the middle of (or in preparation of) trial.

     

    Leave a Comment